The last paragraph of the arrest report is the one that mattered. It read: "This report was generated with assistance from Truleo AI. The content reflects the officer's own observations and recollections."

That sentence got a man accused of driving 100 miles an hour drunk on I-10 released from custody.

The stop

At about 12:33 a.m. on Oct. 29, a DPS trooper clocked a Dodge Charger at roughly 100 mph on Interstate 10 in Phoenix, in a 65 zone. The driver was Anthony Edward Rene Quidera, 37. According to the report, the trooper smelled "the odor of an intoxicating beverage emitting from his breath" and found "several open containers" in the car. Quidera was booked on DUI, speeding and open container. He is presumed innocent.

On its face, a routine arrest. The kind troopers make every night of the week.

The hearing

At Quidera's initial appearance in Maricopa County Superior Court, Commissioner Daniel Fenzel read to the bottom of the probable cause statement and stopped at the disclaimer. His ruling was short. "The court is unable to meaningfully weigh whether the factual allegations made in the narrative were authored, whether in whole or in part, by a generative AI. Therefore, the court is unable to determine probable cause at this time."

Quidera was released. Fenzel said the order did not mean the case could not go forward. An arraignment was set for the following Thursday. Quidera did not show up.

What DPS says the rules are

DPS has used Truleo since 2024. A department spokesman declined to comment on the case itself, but Raul Garcia, who represents DPS, laid out the policy. "Under Department policy, AI tools may be used only as an aid in preparing a report narrative," he said. "The trooper remains the author of the report and is responsible for its accuracy and completeness."

Before submitting, Garcia said, the trooper must review the draft against body camera footage and other evidence, "verify times, names, locations, and actions, and correct any errors." A supervisor must review it before it becomes part of the record. Troopers cannot use the tool until they complete department-approved training.

Read that policy twice. It is a good policy. The trooper reviews, the supervisor reviews, the human stays the author. And none of it answered the question the judge asked, which was simpler: which words in front of me did the trooper write, and which did the machine?

Systems note

This show is for the men and women who make these stops at half past midnight. So here is the honest version.

The trooper did nothing wrong by policy. The report disclosed the AI, which is more than most reports in this country do. And a judge still could not find probable cause, because a disclaimer that says "the content reflects the officer's own observations" is a promise, not a record. Nothing in the report let the court check that promise.

Sean Harrington, who runs the AI and Legal Technology Lab at ASU's law school, told Arizona's Family this will come up again. He is right. Every agency in the Valley is either using these tools or being pitched them, and the pitch is always the same: your officers spend less time typing and more time on the road. That is a real benefit for departments that are hundreds of officers short.

But the arrest report is the thing a judge reads to decide whether a person stays in a cell. If the tool helps write it, the department needs a way to show a court what the tool did. A draft history. A redline. Something. Otherwise the next DUI suspect walks the same way, and it will not be the judge's fault, and it will not be the trooper's.

DPS should fix this before a case that matters more than a speeding DUI goes the same way. We are in service.

This piece draws on Maricopa County Superior Court statements and Arizona DPS statements as reported by Arizona's Family, ABC News, the ABA Journal and WSB. The case remains open and Quidera is presumed innocent. Corrections and information: [email protected].

Keep Reading